12 Comments
User's avatar
Henry Farrell's avatar

It occurs to me that under "Books That Defy Description" you might enjoy M. John Harrison's "Wish I Was Here" (also his novel, The Course of the Heart, which is more conventional in structure but gorgeously weird in the ways that count).

BDM's avatar

hard agree!

John Gu's avatar

Beautifully done roundup!

Javi's avatar

wake up babe celine dropped another banger

Divyasri Krishnan's avatar

Celine!! This is so kind. I admire your work so much, so touched you’ve found something to admire in mine. 🫶🏽

Christine Tsai Taylor's avatar

What a remarkable best of 2025 list! It's so tempting to be overwhelmed and feel like I'm not reading enough.... but I'm not taking that path. Instead, seeing the inherent value in taking notes on everything you read in a year. It's a remarkable discipline!

Brenna Lee's avatar

Thank you for this intriguing list, Celine! I'm curious to know -- and perhaps you've already written about this elsewhere -- do you have a particular method for _how_ you discover and curate the books you read in the first place?

cammi's avatar

Taking notes! You have the best recommendations!

Caroline Beuley's avatar

Currently reading a ton of YA Fantasy so I can find comps for my querying, but as soon as I'm done, I'm coming right back to this list and starting with the "high velocity" novels -- this looks like a great list! Thanks for compiling it Celine!

Jacqui Devaney's avatar

Adding so many of these to my library hold list. I've had Remainder on my shelf since reading Zadie's NYRB piece about it. Loved & Missed has stayed with me in all the months since I've read it. I've never had such satisfying catharsis while reading a book.

Alex Gamela's avatar

"Remainder" is a fun book to read, and it felt better because I had just seen "Synedoche, NY". There's a lot of cool stuff to dig into in this list.

I miss having friends suggesting books to read and movies to watch while having a real live conversation, so, yeah, I agree "you can use the internet to deepen your literary experiences."

Thank you.

Keith McCartney's avatar

Not seen the movie either but it's got Bertolucci's The Dreamers (via Gilbert Adair) vibes.